Print   Close Window

 

Note: Large images and tables on this page may necessitate printing in landscape mode.

Copyright ©2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies.  All rights reserved.

Emergency Medicine Atlas > Part 2. Specialty Areas > Chapter 15. Child Abuse > Physical Abuse >

 

 

Inflicted Burns

Associated Clinical Features

Burns in children are frequently the result of child abuse. The most common types of pediatric burns from abuse are immersion burns and contact burns. Certain clues may assist the physician in differentiating accidental burns from inflicted burns, but often considerable doubt remains even after a careful evaluation.

In an immersion burn, a thoughtful assessment of the pattern and location of the burns, as well as of the unaffected areas, helps to differentiate between accidental and inflicted burns. Postulate possible mechanisms for the injury and correlate the assessment with the given history. A child who is held firmly and deliberately immersed has burn margins that are sharp and distinct. If the child has little opportunity to struggle, few or no burns from splashing liquid will occur. In contrast, a child who accidentally comes into contact with a hot liquid will move about in an attempt to escape further injury. This movement causes the burn margins to be less distinct and may result in additional small burns as hot liquid splashes onto the skin. Children who are "dipped" into a bath of hot water often show sparing of their feet and/or buttocks because they are held firmly against the tub's bottom (Fig. 15.1). A child who has had a hand dipped into hot water and held there may reflexively close the fingers, sparing the palm and fingertips.

Figure 15.1

 

Immersion Burns Immersion burns are often associated with toilet training accidents. This girl was plunged into hot water after soiling herself. She shows sparing of the buttocks, which contacted the surface of the bathtub and avoided being burned. (Courtesy of The Visual Diagnosis of Child Physical Abuse. American Academy of Pediatrics, 1994.)

 

Contact burns usually have a distinct and recognizable shape. Contact burn patterns most commonly associated with abuse include burns from curling irons, hair dryers, heater elements, and cigarettes (Figs. 15.2, 15.3, 15.4, 15.5). A child who has multiple contact burns or burns to areas that are unlikely to come in contact with the hot object accidentally should be evaluated for abuse.

Figure 15.2

 

Contact Burn (Curling Iron) Burns on the chest and abdomen from a curling iron. The burn pattern on the injured skin indicates multiple contact burns from an object the size and shape of a curling iron. Accidental curling iron burns occur, but because this infant has so many burns, the injury is suspicious for abuse. Child abuse should be suspected and reported unless the historian can provide a plausible explanation of how these burns occurred accidentally. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.3

 

Contact Burn (Hair Dryer) The heated grid from the end of a hair dryer caused this child's burns. The burn size and pattern marks of the burn matched exactly the hair dryer grid that was found in the child's home. The history of accidental injury was thought to be unlikely, and child abuse was suspected. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.4

 

Contact Burn (Heater Grate) This child was held against a heater grate. The pattern became more obvious with the child's knee flexed—the position of the leg at the time of the injury. (Courtesy of David W. Munter, MD.)

 

Figure 15.5

 

Contact Burn (Cigarette) Cigarette burns are circular injuries with a diameter of about 8 mm. It can be difficult for the clinician to determine if the burn is from an accidental injury or from abuse. Children who accidentally run into a lit cigarette often have burns to the face or distal extremities. Accidental burns may be less distinct and deep compared with inflicted burns. A report of alleged child abuse should be made if there are multiple cigarette burns, burns to locations unlikely to come into contact with a cigarette accidentally, or other signs that suggest abuse. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Some burn look-alikes may be confused with child abuse. Impetigo (Fig. 15.6) may be mistaken for healing cigarette burns, and bullous impetigo can resemble second-degree burns. Contact dermatitis and cellulitis may resemble first-degree burns.

Figure 15.6

 

Impetigo These circular lesions of impetigo resemble healing cigarette burns. (Courtesy of Michael J. Nowicki, MD.)

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Document thoroughly all burns that may be due to abuse. Draw sketches and take photographs of the injuries. Obtain a skeletal survey in children under the age of 2 years. Report any suspected abuse immediately to the local child protective agency before discharge from the ED. Provide standard burn therapy.

Clinical Pearls

1. Evaluate the alleged history carefully and obtain sufficient details before making any judgment. Assess whether the explanation and history that are given of the alleged episode are inconsistent with the injuries and/or with the child's developmental abilities. Suspect abuse if, without convincing explanation, the historian alters the initial history.

2. Maintain a high index of suspicion whenever caring for a pediatric burn patient. Look carefully for other signs of abuse, such as bruising, fractures, or signs of neglect.

3. Accidental burns from a cigarette are usually single, superficial, and not completely round. Common sites of accidental cigarette burns are the face, trunk, and hands.

4. Report suspicions to the mandated child protection agency whenever a burn may have been deliberately inflicted.

5. Injuries due to suspected child abuse may be photographed without parental consent in most states.

 

Inflicted Bruises and Soft-Tissue Injuries

Associated Clinical Features

Bruises are the most common manifestation of physical child abuse. Child abuse should be suspected whenever bruises are (1) over soft body areas, such as the thighs, buttocks (Fig. 15.7), cheeks, abdomen, and genitalia, since common childhood activities do not commonly cause trauma to these areas; (2) more numerous than usual; (3) of different ages (suggests repeated episodes of abuse); (4) the shape of objects such as belts, cords, or hands (demonstrates that the injuries were inflicted) (Figs. 15.8, 15.9, 15.10); or (5) noted in young, nonambulating children (infants are not capable of getting into accidents).

Figure 15.7

 

Gluteal Fold Bruises This injury to the buttocks demonstrates linear, parallel bruises near the gluteal folds. Forceful spanking causes gluteal fold bruises. They do not indicate a separate trauma in addition to the spanking. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.8

 

Looped Pattern Markings Loop marks are clearly seen within the bruising on this child's back. The loop marks indicate that an extension cord, belt, or some similar object was used to punish him. The color of the bruise is red, which indicates that the injury is only a few days old. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.9

 

Hand-Print Bruise Bruise from a slap showing the outline of her father's hand is clearly seen on the back of this adolescent. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.10

 

Linear Bruises These linear, parallel bruises on the buttocks with unaffected skin between them are indicative of an injury caused by an object. The width of the object can be determined by measuring the space between the parallel lines. Common objects that cause injuries like these, include belts, fingers, cords, and rulers. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

The color of the ecchymosis will change as healing progresses. New injuries are usually red and purple. They may also be tender and swollen. Within a few days, the bruise may turn blue, then green, then yellow, and finally brown. The shape and margins of the bruise become less distinct as it heals. The time period in which these color changes occur is variable. Some bruises resolve within a few days, whereas others resolve over weeks. The amount of time until resolution depends on factors such as the location, size, and depth of the injury.

Bite marks (Figs. 15.11, 15.12, 15.13) have special forensic characteristics that should be recorded. The size, shape, and pattern of the injury can identify a specific perpetrator. Most human bite injuries are caused by children, not adults, but recognition of an adult bite is important because the injury represents abuse. Compared with an adult's, the shape of a child's bite is rounder. If the impressions from the canines are visible in the bite, the perpetrator's age can be estimated. Most children under 8 years of age have less than 3 cm between their canines. Some bites have saliva within the center of the bite, which can also be used to identify the perpetrator. Although some bite marks are immediately obvious during the initial inspection, others can be difficult to recognize. If an adult bite is suspected but unprovable because distinct impressions of the teeth are absent, reexamination of the injury a few days later may facilitate recognition and documentation.

Figure 15.11

 

Bite Mark (Child) Distinct impressions of teeth are seen in this injury. The shape of the injury outlines the upper and lower oral arches. Note the size of the mother's mouth in relation to the size of the bite on the neck, making an adult mouth an unlikely source. (Courtesy of Kevin J. Knoop, MD, MS.)

 

Figure 15.12

 

Bite Mark (Adult) This bite mark is on a young girl's breast. Note the larger size of the wound, which is more consistent with an adult bite. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.13

 

Bruises Bruises cover this child's left arm. The circular bruise on the upper arm is a human bite. Saliva from the perpetrator will usually be present within the center of the bite if the injury is acute and the skin has not yet been washed. Moistened swabs should be used to transfer the saliva from the skin onto the gauze. This gauze must be saved for DNA analysis. As with all trace evidence, the chain of evidence must be documented. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

The bites of animals are usually easy to distinguish from human bites. The size is usually smaller and the shape of the arch mark is narrower than a human's. Sharp animal canines often cause tearing of the skin instead of the crushing seen in human bites.

Differential Diagnosis

Bleeding disorders—such as idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP), Henoch-Schönlein purpura, and leukemia—can mimic child abuse. Folk remedies, such as cupping and coining, may result in soft tissue findings that are not reportable as abuse (see "Lesions Mistaken for Abuse," below).

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Completely undress the child and look for additional signs of abuse (Figs. 15.14 and 15.15). Obtain a complete history of all injuries. Sketch and photograph the injuries. Obtain a platelet count and bleeding studies [prothrombin time and partial thromboplastin time (PT and PTT)] to rule out a bleeding diathesis as the cause of the findings. For children under 2 or 3 years of age who have extensive injuries, obtain a skeletal survey, alanine transferase (ALT), aspartate aminotransferase (AST), amylase, and urinalysis.

Figure 15.14

 

Pinch Marks on Pinna Children may be pulled up or along by their ears, causing this injury. A child's ears should be inspected for this injury whenever abuse is suspected. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.15

 

Strangulation Bruise This child was beaten while at the sitter's and suffered circumferential linear neck abrasions consistent with attempted strangulation. There is also occipital ecchymosis from the abuse. (Courtesy of Barbara R. Craig, MD.)

If human bites are found or suspected, consider consultation with a forensic dentist. If appropriate, collect swabs for DNA forensic analysis from the center of unwashed, fresh bites, which may contain saliva from the perpetrator.

Report suspected abuse to the legally mandated child protection agency before the child is discharged from the ED.

Clinical Pearls

1. Determination of the age of a bruise is imprecise. Bruises that are "fresh" (< 48 h) are usually recognizable because they are tender, red, and swollen. Occasionally, bruises may not be visible for up to 48 h after an injury.

2. Children may deny abuse when questioned because of threats made to them. The child in Fig. 15.16 initially denied that he had been gagged. He told the examining physician that he had spilled some cleaning fluid onto his lips.

3. When a parent or caretaker inflicts an injury while disciplining a child, the incident must be reported to the local child protection agency. Even if corporal punishment is lawful in a given state, the infliction of an injury is never lawful.

4. Place a millimeter ruler or coin next to a pattern injury before taking photographs so that measurements can be made.

5. Consent is not required in most states to photograph injuries suspicious for child abuse.

Figure 15.16

 

Gagging Bruise This child had a sock stuffed into his mouth and tied around his head. The bruises in the corners of the child's mouth are indicative of gagging. Additionally, there are circular bruises on his left and right cheeks caused from the perpetrator's fingers while holding the child still to insert the sock. Pattern markings within the bruises match the fabric pattern of the sock. Photographs of these patterns should be obtained and provided to the police. The red color of the bruises and the fresh facial excoriations indicate that the injuries are recent. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Lesions Mistaken for Abuse

Associated Clinical Features

Whenever bruising is excessive, is not associated with a compatible history, or occurs in an unusual distribution, seek a specific etiology. It may be appropriate to suspect and report child abuse when these conditions exist but also consider other diagnoses.

Common Childhood Bruising

Accidental trauma can result in a bruise to any part of the body, but the forehead and the extensor surfaces of the tibia, elbow, and knee are the most common locations. When other areas of the body are bruised, etiologies other than accidental bruising should be considered.

Mongolian Spots

Mongolian spots are bluish sacral or truncal lesions, most often seen in non-Caucasian infants and young children. They may be mistaken for bruises. Mongolian spots may be limited to only a few lesions, or they may extend up the back and shoulders of the child (Fig. 15.17).

Figure 15.17

 

Mongolian Spots Numerous mongolian spots on this youngster extend up the back and shoulders. (Courtesy of Douglas R. Landry, MD.)

Cupping, Coining, and Moxibustion

Asian families sometimes practice traditional cures with their children, such as cupping, coining, and moxibustion. Each of these practices leaves markings on the child's skin, which may be interpreted as child abuse. In cupping, a flammable object is ignited and placed into a cup. After the flames have extinguished, the cup is inverted and placed onto the child's skin. As the warm air within the cup cools, a vacuum is produced. This "cure" leaves circular suction markings on the child's skin but should not be painful to the child. Coining (Fig. 15.18) is done by rubbing a coin up and down the child's back, just lateral to the spine. This results in petechiae and chronic skin changes on the back. Coining should also not be painful to the child. Neither of these practices should be reported as child abuse. In moxibustion, a flammable object, such as a thread, is ignited on or near the child's skin. Moxibustion may cause superficial burns. Whether moxibustion is reported as child abuse would depend on the physical findings and the judgment of the physician.

Figure 15.18

 

Coining (Cheut Sah or Cao Gio) This child has petechiae and bruising along her spine. Her parents were practicing the Southeast Asian practice of coining, a healing remedy, in which a coin is rubbed along the spine to heal an illness. Coining should not be painful and is not considered abusive. (Courtesy of Charles Schubert, MD.)

Henoch-Schönlein Purpura

Henoch-Schönlein purpura (HSP) is a vasculitis of the small blood vessels. The skin lesions are usually small, symmetric, palpable purpuras. They may appear in a linear pattern and are often confined to the lower extremities (Fig. 15.19). Associated symptoms may include joint and abdominal pain.

Figure 15.19

 

Henoch-Schönlein Purpura (HSP) This child has palpable purpura on the extensor surfaces of the legs. HSP should be considered whenever there is symmetric ecchymosis along the extensor surfaces of the extremities and buttocks. The illness is most often seen in school-age children. Migratory arthritis and abdominal pain may be present. (Courtesy of Ralph A. Gruppo, MD.)

Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura

Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) is an acquired platelet disorder that results in abnormal bleeding. It is most common in 1- to 4-year-old children. The presenting complaint is most often abnormal bruising. The bruises can appear anywhere on the body and are numerous, mimicking child abuse. The child may also have epistaxis, hematuria, or other bleeding.

Hemophilia

Hemophilia is usually diagnosed soon after birth because of abnormal bleeding. The ecchymosis and soft-tissue swelling are greater than would be expected given the history of trauma (Figs. 15.20, 15.21).

Figure 15.20

 

Hemophiliac with Bruising This child's bruising is due to factor VIII deficiency. The degree of bleeding within the ecchymosis is more extensive than that seen in children without coagulopathies. A history of other abnormal bleeding episodes or a history that the child suffers from a coagulopathy is most often obtained at the time of presentation. (Courtesy of Ralph A. Gruppo, MD.)

 

Figure 15.21

 

Grey Turner's Sign This child presented after a minor fall. This pattern of bruising (flank ecchymosis) should alert the examiner to the possibility of retroperitoneal bleeding, which was found on CT scan in this hemophiliac patient. (Courtesy of Louis LaVopa, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Diagnostic suspicion and awareness of the above conditions is the most important step leading to the correct diagnosis. HSP, mongolian spots, and cultural practices such as moxibustion and cupping are diagnosed clinically. If ITP or other thrombocytopenic disorders are suspected, a platelet count is diagnostic. Newborns and infants with significant bleeding should have PT and PTT tests to rule out a coagulopathy.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

A hematologist should be consulted for children with platelet disorders and coagulopathies. HSP requires supportive care and close follow-up. The most serious complication of HSP is bowel obstruction from intussusception.

Clinical Pearls

1. Mongolian spots are noted first in the newborn period.

2. Consider HSP in school-age children with purpura of the lower extremities.

3. Consider ITP in preschool children who have multiple ecchymosis and petechiae without other signs or indications of abuse.

4. Vitamin K deficiency is a cause of bleeding in infancy.

5. Trauma to the forehead may cause bilateral eye ecchymosis (Fig. 15.22) within a few days and can be mistaken for eye trauma.

Figure 15.22

 

Raccoon Eyes, or Black Eyes The etiology of this child's raccoon eyes was a forehead hematoma. He fell onto his forehead a few days earlier and developed a hematoma, a common accidental injury. As the hematoma healed, blood from the hematoma tracked down along the facial soft tissues and settled under his eyes. The resulting ecchymosis suggests that he was punched, leaving him with two black eyes. The absence of other trauma about the eyes—such as lacerations, abrasions, soft tissue swelling, or eye injury—should cause the examiner to consider a diagnosis other than direct trauma. Observation or palpation of forehead soft tissue swelling results in the correct diagnosis. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Fractures Suggestive of Abuse

Associated Clinical Features

Certain fractures should always raise a suspicion of child abuse, such as metaphyseal corner fractures, rib fractures, fractures in a nonambulating child, and untreated healing fractures. Fractures incompatible with the history and those for which no explanation is available are also suspicious of child abuse (Figs. 15.23, 15.24, 15.25, 15.26, 15.27, 15.28, and 15.29).

Figure 15.23

 

Healing Corner Fracture This radiograph shows a healing metaphyseal corner fracture of the proximal tibia, sometimes referred to as a bucket-handle fracture. Arrows point to the impressive periosteal elevation, causing the bucket-handle appearance. This fracture is most often seen in children who have been the victims of child abuse, the result of shaking or pulling. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.24

 

Healing Corner Fracture Periosteal reaction (arrow) of the distal tibia from a corner fracture. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.25

 

Spiral Femur and Proximal Tibia Fracture This radiograph shows a displaced spiral femur fracture with faint callus formation. The age of the fracture is just over 10 days. There is also periosteal reaction of the proximal tibia, which is more solid and therefore older than the femur fracture. Spiral femur fractures are caused by trauma that includes a twisting, rotational force to the bone. Accidental falls can result in spiral fractures if the child's foot is fixed while his or her body is rotating. Spiral fractures from abuse are often caused by an angry adult who twists the leg of the child. The radiographic finding in this photograph is almost certainly indicative of child abuse because there are two injuries which occurred at different times and no treatment was obtained when the injuries occurred. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.26

 

Healing Fracture of the Distal Humerus The periosteal reaction along the distal humerus dates this fracture as older than 10 days. No treatment was obtained for the acute injury. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.27

 

Multiple Healing Rib Fractures There are healing rib fractures of the right posterior fifth, sixth, and seventh ribs, the right lateral sixth rib, the left posterior fourth rib, and the right proximal humerus. The surrounding callus indicates the fractures are older than 10 days. Rib fractures must always raise a suspicion of child abuse since accidental rib fractures are unusual. Rib fractures are usually due to very firm squeezing and may be seen with shaken baby syndrome. Normal handling of infants or playful activities do not cause rib fractures. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.28

 

Compression Fracture The wedging of T-12 (arrow) and probably L-1 indicates vertebral compression fractures. These fractures are the result of significant forces applied to the spinal column and are often indicative of child abuse. (Courtesy of Alan E. Oestreich, MD.)

 

Figure 15.29

 

"Bucket-Handle" Fracture Metaphyseal fractures may appear as in this photograph. When captured at this angle, the fracture is frequently described as a bucket-handle fracture. (Courtesy of Michael P. Poirier, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Normal pediatric radiographic variants, periosteal changes caused by conditions other than healing fractures, and illnesses that cause fragile bones may all be mistaken for fractures due to child abuse. A pediatric radiologist should be consulted if any doubt exists about the radiographic interpretation. Specific disorders that can be mistaken for child abuse include osteogenesis imperfecta, copper deficiency, osteopetrosis, rickets, scurvy, hypervitaminosis A, osteomyelitis, tumors, leukemia, prostaglandin E overdose, and Caffey's infantile cortical hyperostosis.

Conditions that cause "brittle bones" must be considered when unexpected fractures are discovered, even though such cases are rare. The most frequently discussed brittle bone disorder is osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), a rare inherited connective-tissue disorder. Associated features seen in some children with OI include blue sclerae, wormian bones (seen on the skull x-ray), and osteopenia. A family history of bone fragility, hearing loss, and short stature is often present. In rare instances, children with OI lack these associated features.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

If abuse is suspected in a child under 2 or 3 years of age, obtain a skeletal survey. The skeletal survey should include a minimum of 19 films (Table 15.1), including frontal views of the appendicular skeleton and frontal and lateral views of the axial skeleton. Coned down views over a joint may be needed for best visualization of metaphyseal injuries. Oblique views are useful for hand, rib, and nondisplaced lone bone-shaft fractures. All images obtained (including those of the chest) should use bone technique. Ideally, all studies should be read by a radiologist while the patient is still in the ED. Consider computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging of the head in infants with skull fractures when abuse is suspected. Suspected abuse must be reported immediately to the appropriate child protection agency. Fractures should be managed appropriately.

Table 15.1 Skeletal Survey for Suspected Child Abuse

 

AP skull

Lateral skull

Lateral cervical spine

AP thorax

Lateral thorax

AP pelvis

Lateral lumbar spine

AP humeri (2)a
 

AP forearms (2)a
 

Oblique hands (15°–20°) (2)a
 

AP femurs (2)a
 

AP tibias (2)a
 

AP feet (2)a
 

 

a Each a separate exposure: can be combined on one film.

Source: Courtesy of Paul Kleinman, MD.

Clinical Pearls

1. Suspect abuse when a child has multiple fractures, fractures of different ages, unsuspected (occult) fractures, or fractures without a consistent trauma history.

2. Accidental trauma that includes rotational forces can result in a spiral fracture.

3. Obtain a skeletal survey in any child under 2 years of age who has injuries suspicious of abuse.

4. Radiographic signs of healing are typically first seen 10 days after a fracture.

5. Fractures that are not immobilized have a larger callus than immobilized fractures.

 

Shaken Baby Syndrome

Associated Clinical Features

Infants who are violently shaken may suffer intracranial injury, commonly referred to as "shaken baby syndrome." Typically, the infant is held by the chest and violently shaken back and forth. This shaking results in subdural hemorrhages and cerebral contusions (Figs. 15-30, 15-31, and 15-32). Most of the victims are under 1 year of age. Some investigators believe that shaking alone is insufficient to cause these injuries and that therefore some blunt head trauma must also occur. The name "shaken impact syndrome" has been suggested to include this mechanism. There are usually no external signs of trauma, although infants who are shaken may also have fractures, abdominal trauma, bruises, and other injuries. Neurologic symptoms such as apnea, seizures, irritability, or altered mental status are commonly seen but may be absent. Retinal hemorrhages (Figs. 15.33, 15.34) are seen in 80% of shaken babies. The hemorrhages may be unilateral or bilateral. Shaken baby syndrome should be strongly considered when retinal hemorrhages are found in any child under 2 years of age.

Figure 15.30

 

Acute Subdural Hematoma There is a crescent-shaped, hyperdense collection, indicating an acute subdural hematoma over the left cerebral hemisphere (arrows). In addition, the brain demonstrates chronic injury from a previous insult, which left the child severely impaired. (Courtesy of William S. Ball, MD.)

 

Figure 15.31

 

Subacute Brain Injury from Shaken Baby Syndrome This noncontrast computed tomography scan demonstrates bilateral subdural collections over the frontal convexity (arrows). (Courtesy of William S. Ball, MD.)

 

Figure 15.32

 

Old Brain Injury from Shaken Baby Syndrome Three months later there is evidence of diffuse cerebral volume loss with multifocal areas of increased density (arrows), representing diffuse cortical and subcortical injury. (Courtesy of William S. Ball, MD.)

 

Figure 15.33

 

Retinal Hemorrhage Multiple retinal hemorrhages are present. (Courtesy of Rees W. Shepherd, MD.)

 

Figure 15.34

 

Retinal Hemorrhages Multiple discreet subhyaloid hemorrhages seen on funduscopic examination in an infant with shaken baby syndrome. (Courtesy of John D. Baker, MD, and Massie Research Laboratories, Inc.)

Differential Diagnosis

Shaken baby syndrome is the most common cause of intracranial injury in infants. Relatively minor trauma, such as a fall off a couch or bed, should not cause intracranial damage unless there are predisposing conditions such as a bleeding disorder or a preexisting intracranial vascular disorder. Retinal hemorrhages in association with intracranial trauma is almost always indicative of shaken baby syndrome.

Findings on computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) that may mimic SBS include benign extraoral fluid collections, glutaric aciduria type, ruptured aneurysm, or arteriovenous malformation.

Retinal hemorrhages may be caused by birth trauma, blunt eye trauma, meningitis, severe hypertension, sepsis, and coagulopathies. The hemorrhages that result from birth usually resolve within 3 weeks. There have been reports of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) causing retinal hemorrhages. Retinal hemorrhages from CPR and mechanisms other than major trauma are typically less extensive than those seen in SBS.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

CT or MRI of the head should be obtained and the patient treated in the usual fashion. A report of suspected child abuse must be made to the child protective agency. A skeletal survey should also be obtained and other injuries noted (Fig. 15.35). An ophthalmologist should follow the patient's retinal injuries.

Figure 15.35

 

Bruises This child was a victim of shaken baby syndrome (SBS). Unlike most victims of SBS, he also has signs of cutaneous injury. Bruises on his right pinna (A) and left upper arm (B) were noted on examination. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Clinical Pearls

1. Child abuse should be suspected in any infant with retinal hemorrhages or facial bruising.

2. Infants with SBS may have no external signs of trauma and minimal neurologic deficits.

3. When retinal hemorrhages are present, an ophthalmologist should be consulted to assist with the differential diagnosis and for medicolegal documentation.

4. SBS is most common in children under 1 year of age.

 

Examination Techniques and Normal Findings

Associated Clinical Features

The genital examination of prepubertal girls is usually limited to inspection of the external genitalia and hymen for injury and infection. An internal inspection is rarely required. Children should first be examined in the "frog-leg" position. The child can lie on the examination table or sit on a parent's lap (Fig. 15.36), whichever makes her most comfortable. Position the patient in a supine position with her knees flexed and out. The soles of her feet should be opposed (Fig. 15.36). Alternatively, the child can be placed in a knee-chest position. The knee-chest position is particularly useful to visualize foreign bodies in the vagina as well as the posterior vaginal rim.

Figure 15.36

 

Child Sitting in Mother's Lap for Genital Examination This young girl is being examined while she sits in her mother's lap. Many young children are less fearful of the examination if they are held by a parent during the examination. Her legs are held in the "frog-leg" position as labial traction is applied. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

First, examine the perineum for trauma, condylomata, herpetic lesions, or discharge. Next examine the hymen. To visualize the hymen, hold the labia majora between the thumb and index fingers of each hand. Apply lateral and posterior traction to the labia while pulling them outward (Fig. 15.37). When done properly, this procedure is not painful and provides excellent visualization of the hymen (Figs. 15-38, 15-39, and 15-40). If the hymen cannot be visualized in the supine frog-leg position, the knee-chest position should be attempted (Fig. 15.41). Examine the hymen for indications of trauma, such as swelling, ecchymoses or tears. In pubertal girls, a Foley catheter can help the examiner inspect the edges of the hymen for injury (Fig. 15.42). To perform this procedure, insert the deflated catheter into the vagina and inflate the catheter balloon with 10 mL of saline. Gentle traction can then be placed on the catheter by pulling until the balloon expands the hymenal edges. By moving the inflated balloon from side to side to different sections of the hymen can be exposed.

Figure 15.37

 

Labial Traction Examination Techniques Hymenal inspection in prepubertal girls is best accomplished in the supine position when lateral (1) and posterior (2) traction to the labia is applied as shown here. (Adapted from Giandino AP et al: A Practical Guide to the Evaluation of Sexual Abuse in the Prepubertal Child. Sage Publications, 1992.)

 

Figure 15.38

 

Effect of Labial Traction on the Appearance of the Prepubertal Introitus These photographs demonstrate how the appearance of the introitus changes using different examination techniques in a prepubertal girl. Each photograph shows the introitus of the same child as different types of labial traction are used. A. Bottom right: Lateral labial traction only. The hymenal introitus is closed and the hymenal margins cannot be visualized. B. Bottom left: More aggressive lateral traction is applied. The introitus is now partially visible. C. Top right and left: Lateral, posterior, and caudal labial traction (as illustrated in 15.37). The introitus is now clearly seen, and the hymen can be adequately inspected for signs of injury. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.39

 

Redundant Hymenal Tissue These photographs show the genitalia of the same patient. Because of redundant hymenal tissue, the introitus appears asymmetric in the top two photos as well as the bottom left. The text describes methods to handle redundant hymen. When the hymen is no longer adherent to itself, the introitus appears symmetric and normal. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.40

 

Normal Pubertal Hymen The hymen is thicker and more redundant in this pubertal child compared to a prepubertal hymen. This redundancy is due to the effects of estrogen and begins during puberty. The hymen at 6 o'clock is not adequately documented by this photograph. Additional examinations—discussed in the above text—should be used to visualize the posterior hymen. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.41

 

Supine and Prone Examination Image (A) of this examination was obtained while the child was supine. The posterior hymen at 6 o'clock appears to be very narrow. When the child was examined in the prone (knee-chest) position (B), the 6 o'clock area, now at the top of the photo, is better seen and is completely normal in appearance. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.42

 

Foley Catheter Technique A Foley catheter inserted into the vaginal subsequently filled with 10 cc saline is used to inspect the hymenal edges for injury. Gentle traction and movement of the inflated balloon from side to side exposes different sections of the hymen. The hymen shown in these photographs is normal. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Techniques

Supine or "frog-leg" position:

1. The child can lie on an examination table or, if more comfortable, can sit on her parent's lap.

2. Position the child in a supine position with her knees out and soles together.

3. Apply traction, as demonstrated in Fig. 15.38.

Prone or knee-chest position:

1. On the examination table, position the child on her hands and knees. Her knees should be spread wider than her shoulders.

2. Have the child rest her chest to the examination table.

3. Maintain the knee placement with a swayed backbone.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

If sexual abuse is suspected, a report of alleged sexual abuse must be made to the child protective agency. Suspicious or abnormal examination findings should be documented. The child should be referred for a definitive examination by an expert in child abuse.

Clinical Pearls

1. Allow the child to sit on her mother's lap during the examination if this makes her more cooperative and less afraid.

2. Speculum examinations are rarely indicated in prepubertal girls and are reserved for removal of an intravaginal foreign body or evaluation of intravaginal trauma. General anesthesia is often required before inserting a speculum into a prepubertal child.

3. Apply caudal traction to the labia during examination to prevent a superficial tear of the posterior fourchette.

4. If a portion of the hymen cannot be visualized because it is adherent to the adjacent labia or to itself, gently touch the adherent tissue with the contralateral labia to pull it free. A drop of saline placed onto the posterior hymen may also separate adherent tissues without causing discomfort to the child.

5. The inner hymenal ring is usually smooth and uninterrupted. Notches at 3 and 9 o'clock are normal.

6. The shape and appearance of the normal prepubertal hymen is variable. Annular (Fig. 15.43) and crescentic (Fig. 15.44) configurations are the most common. Normal hymens may also be septate (Fig. 15.45), imperforate (no central opening), or cribriform (multiple small openings).

7. A normal examination does not exclude sexual abuse. The majority of abused prepubertal girls have normal genital examinations. Examination findings specific for sexual abuse are found in approximately 10 to 20% of girls who allege abuse.

Figure 15.43

 

Normal Annular Hymen The hymen in this prepubertal girl is annular in shape, extending completely around the vaginal opening. The inner hymenal ring (introitus) is smooth and free of any defects, such as lacerations or scars. The color of the hymen is more deeply red than seen in pubertal women and does not necessarily indicate infection or trauma. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.44

 

Normal Crescentic Hymen The hymen in this prepubertal girl extends from 2 to 10 o'clock and is absent beneath the urethra between 10 and 2 o'clock. This annular shape is very common and should not be mistaken for trauma or rupture of the superior (2 to 10 o'clock) section. The inner hymenal ring (the introitus) is smooth and free of any defects, such as lacerations or scars. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.45

 

Normal Septate Hymen This prepubertal girl has a septum in the center of her introitus. Hymenal septa are rarely seen after puberty. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Injuries and Findings Due to Sexual Abuse

Associated Clinical Features

Sexual abuse must be considered in any child with a genital or rectal injury, a sexually transmitted infection, a history of alleged abuse, or symptoms or behaviors seen in abused children.

Acute injuries include lacerations, bruises, abrasions and swelling (Figs. 15-46, 15-47, 15-48, and 15-49). Acute injuries heal quickly, often within a few days to a week. Nonacute findings of trauma secondary to sexual abuse can be more difficult to recognize and should be considered by a child abuse expert. Nonacute findings include scars, absent hymen, abnormal clefts (Fig. 15.50), and anal changes. Accurate interpretation of genital findings is dependent on examination technique (see preceding section for suggestions on examination technique).

Figure 15.46

 

Hymenal Injury Healed injuries to the vaginal introitus have caused significant distortion of the anatomy. The vaginal opening is gaping revealing multiple vaginal rugae. Only small remnants of the hymen remain.

 

Figure 15.47

 

Hymenal Laceration An acute laceration with bruising of the posterior fourchette. The nearby hymen is edematous and ecchymotic. This injury is most likely less than 72 h old. Injuries to the hymen and posterior fourchette are usually indicative of sexual assault. Forensic specimens should be collected after acute sexual assault when the history or examination findings suggest that semen, saliva, hair, or blood from the perpetrator might be recovered from the victim. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.48

 

Acute Rectal Trauma An acute rectal injury is visible at 12 o'clock. The perianal skin may normally be darker, with red or blue coloration, than the surrounding skin. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.49

 

Acute Hymenal Trauma There is a deep laceration of the hymen at 7 o'clock and ecchymosis of the hymen at 6 o'clock after recent sexual assault. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.50

 

Gaping Introitus, Absent Hymen The hymen is almost totally absent in this prepubertal girl. There may be a slight rim of hymen at 6 o'clock. The hymen in young girls is often very thin and may be totally destroyed after vaginal penetration. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Sexually transmitted infections diagnosed in a young person may indicate sexual abuse (Fig. 15.51). Children infected with Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Chlamydia trachomatis, Trichomonas, and syphilis (Fig. 15.52) who did not become infected through perinatal transmission have almost certainly been infected through sexual contact. Condylomata acuminata (genital warts) (Fig. 15.53) and herpes simplex may be transmitted through sexual or nonsexual contact, so that sexual abuse as well as other mechanisms should be considered.

Figure 15.51

 

Vaginal Discharge Copious white discharge is present in this photograph. Vaginal discharge in a prepubertal child may be an indication of an STD. All children with vaginal discharge should be cultured for N. gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.52

 

Perirectal Condyloma Lata (Secondary Syphilis) Perirectal condyloma lata are visible around the rectum. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Figure 15.53

 

Perirectal Condylomata Acuminata (Warts) Multiple perianal (A) and perihymenal (B) condyloma acuminata are visible in these photographs. Both individual and multidigitate lesions are seen. The hymen appears to be normal. (Courtesy of Charles J. Schubert, MD.)

All children who allege sexual abuse should be evaluated, treated, and protected from the alleged perpetrator. Because of threats by family members or the perpetrator, it is not unusual for a child to recant initial allegations of sexual abuse. Although uncommon, some children falsely allege sexual abuse. The determination of whether allegations are false or of the significance of recantation should be made by the child protective services worker or by law enforcement, not by the emergency physician.

Behaviors or symptoms of abuse are frequently absent at the time of diagnosis but can include fear or avoidance of an individual, genital or rectal pain, sleep disorders, regression, enuresis, encopresis, sexual acting out or promiscuity, depression, declining in school performance, and perpetration of sexual abuse on younger victims.

Differential Diagnosis

Injury to the hymen from an event other than sexual abuse is possible though unusual. Masturbation and self-exploration do not cause vaginal injury in the vast majority of children. Subtle findings of hymenal trauma are difficult to recognize. Normal hymenal anatomy may be misdiagnosed as trauma by inexperienced examiners. Other genital findings mistaken for sexual abuse are listed in the next section.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Report suspected or alleged sexual abuse to the appropriate child protection agency. Clearly document all examination findings. If injuries require repair, appropriate consultation with surgery or gynecology should be made. Culture for sexually transmitted infections if there is a vaginal or urethral discharge. If the history of abuse suggests a risk for infection, obtain cultures from the genitalia, rectum, and pharynx. Consider syphilis and HIV testing. Obtain forensic specimens if the alleged abuse occurred within the previous 72 h and the examination findings or history suggests that blood, semen, saliva, or hair of the perpetrator might be found on the victim's body. Offer sexually transmitted disease (STD) and pregnancy prophylaxes when indicated. Make discharge plans in consultation with the child protection worker so that the child is not returned to the abusive environment.

Clinical Pearls

1. It is not necessary to measure the vaginal opening of prepubertal girls. The size of the introitus is dependent on examination technique, degree of patient relaxation, patient age, and other variables. There is no consensus on normal introitus size among experts.

2. Hymenal notches at 3 and 9 o'clock can be a normal finding.

3. Changes to the posterior hymen, such as narrowing and notching, may be indicative of penetrating injury.

4. Rectal abuse often results in no visible trauma. When trauma does occur, healing may be complete within 1 to 2 weeks, leaving no visible indication of the injury.

5. The external anus is darker in color than the rest of the skin and should not be mistaken for erythema from abuse or infection.

6. Consider sexual abuse when significant anal fissures are present on examination.

7. Condyloma lata (syphilis) can be mistaken for condylomata acuminata (warts).

8. Vaginal discharge in a prepubertal child should always be cultured for Neisseria gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia.

9. When nits are observed in the eyelashes of children (Fig. 15.54), the infecting louse is the pubic louse. The mode of transmission must be sought and sexual abuse must be suspected.

Figure 15.54

 

Nits Nits (the larval form of the louse) from Phthirus pubis are seen firmly adherent to the eyelashes in this child. Sexual abuse should be considered. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

 

Straddle Injury

Associated Clinical Features

Straddle injuries are a frequent cause of genital trauma and most often result in unilateral abrasions, bruising, and hematomas of the labia majora and clitoral hood (Fig. 15.55). A clear history describing the straddle injury should be given by the caretaker.

Figure 15.55

 

Straddle Injury Laceration of the clitoral hood due to a fall onto the bar of a bicycle. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Sexual abuse must be considered in all children with genital injuries. Injuries involving the hymen are not typical of straddle injuries and are usually the result of sexual abuse or assault.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Check for urethral injury. Sitz baths and Polysporin ointment promote healing and minimize discomfort. If the child has difficulty voiding, she should be encouraged to void in a bath of warm water.

Clinical Pearls

1. Straddle injuries usually present with a clear mechanism of injury and a physical examination that supports the history.

2. Straddle injuries do not typically involve the hymen or internal vaginal mucosa.

 

Labial Adhesions

Associated Clinical Features

Adhesions of the labia minora occur in young girls and may persist until puberty. A thin translucent line is seen where the labia meet (Fig. 15.56). The extent of the adhesions varies from child to child. Involvement is often limited to the posterior portion of the labia, but some children have more extensive adhesions completely obscuring the introitus. It is postulated that vulvar irritation and poor hygiene contribute to the etiology of labial adhesions.

Figure 15.56

 

Labial Adhesions Labial adhesions obscure the hymen in this prepubertal girl. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

The hymen and introitus may be obscured by the adhesions. If the adhesions are unrecognized, a diagnosis of hymenal trauma and "gaping" introitus may be incorrectly made. Adhesions may be mistaken for vaginal scars.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Estrogen cream (Premarin) can be prescribed and applied gently over the adhesions twice daily for 2 to 4 weeks. Recurrence is not uncommon.

Clinical Pearls

1. Adhesions may be congenital or acquired.

2. It is postulated that vulvar irritation from sexual abuse may cause labial adhesions, but clear supporting evidence is lacking.

 

Urethral Prolapse

Associated Clinical Features

Prepubertal girls with urethral prolapse present with vaginal bleeding, vaginal mass, or urinary complaints. On examination, an annular, erythematous vaginal mass is seen (Fig. 15.57). Upon close examination, the mass can be seen to originate from the urethra. If necrotic, the mass is friable.

Figure 15.57

 

Urethral Prolapse A round reddish-purple mass is seen in this child's introitus. Careful examination reveals that the mass originates from the urethra. (Courtesy of Michael P. Poirier, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Urethral prolapse may be mistaken for vaginal injury, sexual abuse, or vaginal mass.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

The prolapse may resolve within a few weeks with conservative medical management consisting of daily sitz baths and topical antibiotics. Topical estrogen cream and oral antibiotic therapy have also been used with some success. Surgical repair is usually not required but may be indicated if necrosis is present or conservative management fails.

Clinical Pearls

1. Urethral prolapse often presents with painless genital bleeding of unknown etiology.

2. Prolapse is more common in African American girls.

 

Toilet Bowl Injury

Associated Clinical Features

Acute bruising to the glans and corona of the penis can occur if the toilet seat falls onto the penis during voiding, trapping the penis between the seat and toilet bowl (Fig. 15.58). This injury is not uncommon in boys of about 3 years of age who are both inexperienced at voiding while standing and are short enough for this injury to occur.

Figure 15.58

 

Toilet Bowl Injury This toddler presented with a straightforward history of the toilet seat falling onto his penis during voiding. Despite the swelling and ecchymosis, he was able to void without difficulty. (Courtesy of Kevin J. Knoop, MD, MS.)

Differential Diagnosis

Genital trauma is always suspicious for sexual abuse. The mechanism of injury may be difficult to determine if the injury was unwitnessed.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

No specific treatment is needed unless the child is unable to void. If the child cannot void, a retrograde urethrogram and urologic consult are indicated.

Clinical Pearl

1. Genital injuries are suspicious of sexual abuse if no appropriate history of accidental trauma is given.

 

Perianal Streptococcal Infection

Associated Clinical Features

Presenting complaints are often rectal pain, itching, bleeding, and rash. Symptoms may be present for months prior to the diagnosis. The child may be constipated because of stool retention and may have recently been given laxatives because of these symptoms. Systemic symptoms are absent. The perianal area is erythematous and tender (Fig. 15.59). The involved area is well demarcated from the uninfected skin. Anal fissures and bleeding may be seen.

Figure 15.59

 

Perianal Streptococcal Infection Intense erythema around the anus consistent with perianal streptococcal infection. (Courtesy of Raymond C. Baker, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

Sexual abuse is often misdiagnosed because of the child's complaints of rectal pain and bleeding and the above findings on examination. This infection can also be mistaken for poor hygiene, dermatitis, nonspecific irritation, and constipation.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Culture or obtain direct antigen studies for group A beta-hemolytic streptococci. Treat with oral penicillin for 10 days. Substitute erythromycin for patients allergic to penicillin. Treatment failures should be treated with IM penicillin and/or oral clindamycin.

Clinical Pearls

1. Direct antigen studies are sensitive (89%) and specific (100%) for perianal group A streptococcal infection.

2. Examine the pharynx for streptococcal infection when considering perianal strep infection.

3. Infection is unusual in children older than 10 years.

 

Lichen Sclerosus Atrophicus

Associated Clinical Features

Lichen sclerosus atrophicus (LSA) is an unusual dermatitis that affects the anogenital area. The diagnosis should be suspected whenever an area of hypopigmentation in the shape of an hourglass is seen around the child's anus and genitalia. The hypopigmented area is caused by small white or yellowish papules which coalesce into large plaques. The affected skin is atrophic and bleeds easily after minor trauma. The hemorrhagic form of LSA includes subepithelial hemorrhagic lesions to the labia and affected skin, which can be mistaken for traumatic lesions (Fig. 15.60). Children may complain of pruritus and dysuria.

Figure 15.60

 

Lichen Sclerosus Atrophicus The perineum surrounding the vagina has a bruised appearance. Atrophic skin is also evident. (Courtesy of Robert A. Shapiro, MD.)

Differential Diagnosis

The findings of hemorrhage around the genitalia and rectum are often mistaken for signs of sexual abuse.

Emergency Department Treatment and Disposition

Use symptomatic treatment if needed; 1%hydrocortisone cream can be prescribed. Refer to dermatologist for treatment.

Clinical Pearl

1. Lichen sclerosus atrophicus is the most common dermatitis mistaken for sexual abuse.

 


Copyright ©2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Notice. Any use is subject to the Terms of Use and Notice.  Additional Credits and Copyright Information.

McGraw-Hill Education

A Silverchair Information System

The McGraw-Hill Companies